They Say / I Say
This is not their report, their file, or their version. This is yours. Same truth, remixed across formats: contrast statement, manifesto, appeal, chapter intro, spoken word, voice-over, and character monologue.
They Say / I Say
Manifesto
I didn’t break the law. I broke their illusion that I would roll over and accept whatever story they wrote about me.
They built a system where paperwork weighs more than blood, where labels travel faster than truth, where a stranger with a clipboard thinks they know my child better than I do. They call it order. I call it a machine that eats fathers alive and spits out case numbers.
I am not a case number. I am a father who remembers exactly what happened while everyone else was busy signing forms and covering their own asses. I was there when the doors that are “supposed” to be open were locked. I was there when the people “trained to help” turned their backs. I was there when asking for help meant being accused.
So I stopped asking.
They say I was reckless. I say I was awake. They say I should have trusted the process. I say the process already failed me long before I raised my voice. They say I’m the threat. I say the real threat is any system that believes it owns a child more than the parent who would die for them.
My duty wasn’t written by their policies. It was written in my bones: protect my own. Stand between my child and harm, whether that harm comes with a criminal record or a government email signature.
I owe my loyalty to the one who calls me Dad — not to the ones who call me “non-compliant.” I owe my truth to the life I tried to shield, not to the lie they tried to stamp on my forehead.
Let them keep their folders and their stories. I keep my memory. I keep my spine. I keep my right to say: this is what really happened.
Appeal-Style Statement (Narrative)
For the record, I wish to make one thing absolutely clear: I did not commit the crime I was accused of. The narrative presented against me was not a neutral description of events, but a story constructed to serve the interests of those in power — not the truth, and certainly not the best interest of my child.
At the time in question, I was a father acting under a duty that predates any statute: the duty to protect my child. The so-called “alternatives” people like to bring up — report it here, escalate it there, trust this office, rely on that agency — were not available in any real, functional way. On paper, they existed. In practice, they failed.
I did not arrive at my decisions lightly, or in chaos, or in malice. I arrived there after systems ignored me, after doors closed, after I was treated less like a parent and more like a problem to be processed.
When I finally did ask for help, I was met not with support, but with suspicion, accusation, and punishment. My vulnerability was used against me. My love for my child was reframed as instability. My resistance to being mislabeled was interpreted as non-cooperation.
I reject that framing.
I acted out of love, out of responsibility, and out of a clear understanding that no third party has a higher claim over my child’s safety than I do. If my refusal to surrender that responsibility makes me inconvenient to their system, then so be it. But inconvenience is not a crime.
The record they wrote may never fully admit what they did. This statement exists so there is at least one document that does: I was not the danger. I was the one standing between my child and it.
Chapter Intro (Book Style)
They will tell you I was wrong before they tell you what they did. That’s how the story is usually introduced — with a warning label.
“He didn’t follow the rules. He had other options. He overreacted.”
You’ll hear all of that before you ever hear what it felt like to stand where I stood. You won’t hear how many doors I knocked on that never opened. You won’t hear how many times I swallowed my pride and asked for help from people who were paid to pretend they cared. You’ll just hear that I became a problem.
This chapter isn’t for them. It’s for the version of you who has ever been told that your reality doesn’t count because it doesn’t match the paperwork. It’s for the parent who knows, in their gut, that something is wrong long before a report is ever stamped and filed.
I didn’t set out to be defiant. I didn’t wake up one day and decide to make enemies with a system. I woke up every day trying to be a father.
This is the story of what happens when love for your child runs head-first into a machine that wants you compliant, quiet, and grateful for whatever scraps of “permission” it hands you. It’s the story of how I refused to let them rename me, redefine me, or erase what actually happened.
They have their version. This book is mine.
Spoken Word / Slam Piece
Cinematic Voiceover
Fade in: A man sitting alone at a table. A single file folder in front of him, thick with paper, thin on truth.
VOICEOVER (DEAN):
They’ll tell you I was the problem long before they ever admit what they did. That’s how this works. You paint the man black, so nobody looks too closely at the hands holding the brush.
They said I was reckless. That I didn’t follow the rules. That there were a dozen other paths I could have taken. Funny how all those paths only seem to show up in hindsight, on a whiteboard, in a meeting room where nobody was there when it mattered.
In the moment, it was just me, my child, and a wall of people who thought paperwork outranked parenthood.
They talk about “support” like it was something they offered. What I remember is asking for help and feeling the floor drop out from under me. Watching their eyes calculate liability instead of humanity. Realizing, in real time, that I wasn’t being heard — I was being processed.
So if you want to know why I did what I did, it’s simple: I chose my child over their comfort. I chose my duty over their narrative. I chose to live with my own conscience instead of their approval.
Maybe that doesn’t play well in their reports. Maybe it never will.
But at the end of the day, when the lights are off and the cameras are gone, I’m the one who has to answer to the man in the mirror — and to the child who once reached for my hand and trusted I would be there.
That’s the only court that ever really mattered to me.
Character Monologue (Dean)
You want to know why I did it? Why I stood up when every voice in the room told me to sit down and be grateful for whatever crumbs of “access” they might sprinkle my way?
It’s because I remember what it means to be a father in a way they never will.
They sat there with their pens and their protocols and their polite little phrases — “We’re just following procedure,” “We’re concerned,” “We’re trying to help” — and every single one of them forgot the simplest law there is: a parent’s duty to protect their own.
Not protect their reputation. Not protect their ego. Protect their child.
They say I could have done it differently. Maybe, if the world had been different. If the doors they love to point at on paper were actually open. If help had been real instead of theoretical. If any of them had looked at me and seen a father instead of a file to be contained.
But that’s not the world I was standing in.
In my world, in that moment, I was alone. Alone with the weight of knowing that if I didn’t act, nobody else was going to step in. Alone with the knowledge that they would rather label me than listen to me.
So I made my choice.
It wasn’t about rebellion. It wasn’t about ego. It wasn’t about proving them wrong. It was about refusing to let them decide who I was to my own child.
They say I’m the problem. I say I’m the one who remembered what love is supposed to look like when the rest of them forgot.
You don’t have to like my answer. You don’t have to approve of it. But if you’re going to ask me why — at least have the courage to hear the truth.